The Potter House, 53 West Church Street, Fairport, NY

Update October 2023 - The property is now sold.
53 West Church Street is now a residential property.
The property closing was held late September.

Is the Potter House for sale?

The Potter House also known as 53 West Church Street is for sale. The purchase offer by Aristo Homes was approved at the May 19th, Village Board Meeting.

Statement from the Village Board May 19, 2021 regarding the sale

Information about the listing:
Media Coverage:
Potter House Listing Advertisement 
Zillow Listing 

  • Any party purchasing the property must adhere to local zoning code.
  • The home is a national landmark and a locally designated historic structure. Any changes to the exterior require a certificate of appropriateness from the Fairport Historic Preservation Commission.
  • The home and the carriage barn have been subdivided from the Potter Memorial site and the rest of Potter Park. The parking lot behind the home belongs to the park not to the home.

Public Meetings - February 2020

Three well attended public meetings were held in February 2020 to allow the public to visit inside the house and to hear about the history and status of the property. Members of the Village Board attended to hear resident and community feedback for ideas of what to do with the house. We heard cherished memories of the past use of the property and several ideas. 

After much discussion of possible uses by the Village Board, it was determined with the amount of repairs needed, it would be cost prohibitive to pursue the proper restoration of the property for public use. 

The Village supports the reuse of this historic property and is looking for a future property owner that will support the home and restore it, showing off the beauty of its history. The one-time funds from this sale will be invested in the Village capital projects fund and used for future projects in the Village of Fairport. These funds will not be utilized for operating expenses. We look forward to having a new community member with the purchase of the home.


2021 Potter House Appraisal Report
The property must listed and sold for at least the value of the appraisal report.

February 2020 Community Meeting Slides  - updated with community input
Community meetings that shared the history of the home and the status of need for rehabilitation of the house. Additionally, brainstorming was encouraged for future use of the property.  

2019 Potter House Engineering Report

2016 Potter House Subdivision Map

The subdivision was completed in 2016 with the desire of the 2016 Village board of trustees to sell the property.
2011 Potter House Engineering Report

Sign up for FAIRPORT ALERTS powered by Everbridge
Choose how your information is delivered by email or text or phone message.